President Barack Obama is looking to businesses and high-income individuals to bring the federal deficit down. In a plan submitted on September 19 to the Joint Select Committee on Deficit Reduction, known as the “supercommittee,” the President offered details for a plan to cut the federal deficit by $3.2 trillion (net) over the next decade.
The plan outlines a variety of proposals that increase corporate tax payments at a time when businesses are struggling to avoid the threat of a double-dip recession. The proposal also includes offsets for the cost of the President’s previously released job creation and infrastructure spending bill, the American Jobs Act (AJA).
The Administration’s push for an increase in business revenues is evident throughout its deficit reduction plan. In summary, the plan includes $1.5 trillion in revenue provisions that:
- Increase taxes on high-income individuals;
- Tighten international tax rules;
- Change rules affecting life insurance companies and their products;
- Eliminate tax provisions that benefit the oil and gas and coal industries; and
- Repeal certain longstanding tax accounting methods.
Less clear is the Administration’s broader view of corporate tax reform. Instead of specifics, the deficit reduction plan sets out five guiding principles for corporate tax reform efforts:
1. Lower individual and corporate tax rates;
2. Broaden the tax base by eliminating “inefficient and unfair” tax breaks;
3. Contribute $1.5 trillion toward deficit reduction over the next decade;
4. Spur economic growth and job creation; and
5. Observe the “Buffett Rule” – a principle rooted in the tenet that households with annual income in excess of $1 million should not have a lower effective tax rate than a typical middle-class family.
The details of the debt-busting plan demonstrate the Administration’s intent of leaning heavily on business to get a handle on the deficit. Partnerships with flow-through income should be aware that the President’s most recent plan allows the 2001 and 2003 ordinary income tax rates to expire for high-income individuals beginning in 2013. With the President’s plan, the expiration of upper-income tax rates is also likely to include reinstating the personal exemption phase-out and itemized deduction limitation to those with “household income above $250,000 per year” (and likely to singles earning above $200,000).
Two big tickets items outlined in the Administration’s plan are expected to fetch $467 billion, enough to fully offset incentives offered in the AJA – a payroll tax holiday for employees and employers, various credits to encourage hiring of veterans and the long-term unemployed, and a delay in the implementation of a 3 percent withholding on payments to government contractors. The deficit reduction offsets are deduction and exclusion limitations and changes in the tax treatment of carried interest.
Itemized deductions and exclusions – The administration would limit to 28 percent the tax rate at which itemized deductions reduce tax liability for high-income taxpayers, effective January 1, 2013. This provision would include certain above-the-line deductions, exclusions for tax-exempt municipal bond interest and foreign-earned income, and the aggregate cost of employer-sponsored group health plan coverage.
Carried interest changes – Under the deficit reduction plan’s carried interest provisions, 100 percent of the income derived from “investment services partnership interests” would be subject to ordinary income treatment for tax years beginning after December 31, 2012. Carried interest income would also be excluded from qualifying income for purposes of determining whether a publicly traded partnership is treated as a corporation, although this provision would not be effective for 10 years. Some partnerships – those owned by real estate investment trusts or other publicly traded partnerships – would receive a permanent carve-out from the rules. Penalties for underpayments would be doubled from 20 percent to 40 percent when property is transferred for investment management services, and reasonable cause exceptions to underpayment penalties for investment management services would be curtailed.
Other proposed tax changes that would impact U.S. businesses are listed below.
- A permanent unemployment insurance tax hike of 0.2 percent.
- Worker reclassification guidance under common law standards.
- International tax rules regarding deferral and pooling of foreign tax credits.
- Current deduction restrictions for interest expenses that are allocated and apportioned to foreign-source income that is not currently subject to U.S. tax.
- Deemed-paid foreign tax credits calculated on consolidated basis for earnings and profits of the foreign subsidiaries that are repatriated to the taxpayer in the current taxable year.
- Excess income from intangible property transfers by U.S. persons to a related controlled foreign corporation subject to a low foreign effective tax rate would be treated as subpart F income. It is not clear if “intangible property” will include workforce in place, goodwill, and going concern value.
- Section 163(j) earnings stripping rules would be changed to prevent inverted companies from using foreign related-party and guaranteed debt to reduce U.S. tax on income from U.S. operations.
- Dual-capacity taxpayers subject to a foreign levy that receive a specific economic benefit from the levying country would lose foreign tax credit claim for the portion of the foreign levy paid for the specific economic benefit.
- Repeal of various tax provisions that benefit oil and gas companies and elimination of certain tax preferences for the coal industry.
- Reinstatement of superfund taxes that include an excise tax of 9.7 cents per barrel on crude oil received at a U.S. refinery and imported; an excise tax on hazardous chemicals sold and imported in substances in to the United States; an excise tax on imported substances that use listed hazardous chemicals as a feedstock; and an environmental tax of 0.12 percent on the amount by which the modified alternative minimum taxable income of a corporation exceeds $2 million.
For questions regarding these proposed changes, or other corporate tax reform issues, please contact Dan DeLau at 720-227-0065 or delau@taxops.com.